EFRAG estimates that around 1,200 non-EU groups will report under ESRS-40a (previously referred to as N-ESRS) from financial years starting in 2028. Under EFRAG's July 2026 exposure draft, the mixed approach lets them limit reporting on topics other than climate to EU-related impacts, but it doesn't suit every business model.
EFRAG's public outreach events held in September and October 2026 have been revealing. What participants said, and how EFRAG responded, tell us a great deal about which groups are likely to benefit from the mixed approach, and which are not.
Key takeaways
- Groups whose EU business is already run separately are most likely to benefit, such as banks and insurers with EU subsidiaries.
- Exporters are likely to gain little, because the upstream value chain of EU-bound products stays in scope.
- Integrated groups may not qualify at all, and EFRAG has sent mixed signals on allocation keys.
- Some groups will skip the mixed approach and report globally or under full ESRS instead.
What is the ESRS-40a mixed approach?
The ESRS-40a mixed approach is an option for non-EU groups reporting under Article 40a of the Accounting Directive, introduced by the CSRD. Climate change (E1) is always reported globally, but for other topics a group can limit reporting to EU-related impacts, topic by topic (or by sub-topic or group of impacts), if it can meaningfully identify them.
It is one of three ways non-EU groups will be able to report: globally under ESRS-40a (the default), using the mixed approach, or voluntarily under full ESRS, which also covers financial risks and opportunities (double materiality).
EFRAG added the mixed approach at the European Commission's request, to match the reporting burden to the extent of a group's link to the EU.
"EU-related impacts" have two parts, and both apply (ESRS-40a 1, paragraph 28):
- location-based: impacts of the group's activities in the EU, including their value chains; and
- customer-based: impacts, wherever they arise, linked to products and services sold, or reasonably assumed to be sold, into the EU.
The mixed approach option is only available if the group passes the paragraph 29 test: it must be able to make a "meaningful identification" of its EU-related impacts, in line with how its business and value chain are structured or managed. The examples in the draft's application requirements (AR 6) include a separate EU segment, EU-specific products and dedicated EU value chains.
Whether the mixed approach reduces reporting therefore depends on two questions: how much of the group's impact the EU-related boundary excludes, and whether the group can pass the test.
Which non-EU groups does the mixed approach suit?
The mixed approach suits groups that run their EU business separately; exporters and globally integrated groups gain less. The preparers who spoke at the outreach events fell broadly into four types, and some fit more than one.
| Type of group | Why it fits or struggles | Examples from the outreach events | Does it reduce reporting? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Separate EU business | EU subsidiaries, products or value chains are already distinct | JPMorgan, China Construction Bank, Chubb, Daikin | Yes, most likely |
| 2. Exporter | Non-EU production and suppliers stay in scope through the customer-based part | Fonterra, Sungrow | A little (depends on the EU share of output) |
| 3. Globally integrated | Shared sites, staff and data systems make EU-related impacts hard to separate | Brambles, Amazon, Alibaba | Possibly not, if it fails the paragraph 29 test |
| 4. Prefers global or full ESRS | Already reports globally, or wants the CSRD subsidiary exemption | Dormakaba, Swiss Finance Council members, Suzano | Not applicable |
Groups with a separate EU business are most likely to benefit
EU-related impacts are easiest to identify when a group already runs its EU business as a distinct entity with its own operations, products or value chains (the examples in AR 6).
Banks and insurers that serve EU clients through EU subsidiaries were the most positive about the mixed approach during the outreach events:
- JPMorgan called the mixed approach "the most workable option" (US outreach event).
- China Construction Bank, whose EU business sits in three entities, found identifying EU-related impacts "relatively straightforward" in the field test (China outreach event).
- Chubb said it liked the concept of the mixed approach for topics beyond climate (Swiss outreach event).
Daikin, the Japanese air-conditioning maker, described how this could work for a manufacturer (Japan outreach event). Its illustrative group has six EU subsidiaries that make more than 95% of its EU sales, and treats them as a "virtual consolidation". The example uses the mixed approach for value chain workers (S2) and circular economy (E5), but reports own workforce (S1) globally, because staff outside the EU who make the products are hard to separate. Gemma Sánchez Danés, EFRAG's Technical Director for Social, said: "That's exactly what we want companies to do."
There is a limit: these groups can't simply report only on their EU entities. Impacts outside the EU that are linked to products and services sold into the EU also count, whichever group entity provides them.
Financial institutions such as JPMorgan and Chubb asked for a narrower boundary that follows their EU business instead.
EFRAG pushed back. Replying to Chubb in the Swiss outreach event, Chiara Del Prete, chair of EFRAG's Sustainability Reporting Technical Expert Group, said EFRAG had considered a boundary based only on EU locations and rejected it, because it would miss impacts outside the EU linked to significant EU sales. Where an entity's EU-related impacts are minor, she said the materiality assessment should filter them out.
So these groups are best placed to benefit from the mixed approach, but they still need to check what they provide into the EU from outside their EU entities.
Exporters are likely to gain little
It's a different picture for exporters. The customer-based part keeps an exporter's home operations in scope. If a group makes products outside the EU and sells them into the EU, the impacts of its factories, farms and suppliers linked to those products are EU-related, wherever they occur.
Fonterra, the New Zealand dairy co-operative, said the mixed approach was unlikely to be highly relevant to its reporting, as it would be hard to argue that impacts on New Zealand dairy farms "were not material when the goods are being sold into Europe" (New Zealand outreach event).
EFRAG put it more broadly in the Mexico outreach event: whether a group reports globally or uses the mixed approach, the value chain is global.
Sungrow, a Chinese maker of solar inverters and battery storage systems that supplies Europe from factories in China, asked to attribute pollution to where it occurs (China outreach event). But as the exposure draft stands, the customer-based part includes those upstream impacts.
So even where exporters can use the mixed approach, the reporting burden won't be reduced by much. They would also have to show how they identified their EU-related impacts and which method they used (ESRS-40a 2, BP-1).
The saving depends on how much of their output goes to the EU: the larger that share, the less the mixed approach removes.
Globally integrated groups may fail the paragraph 29 test
Where factories, staff and systems serve every market, EU-related impacts are hard to separate.
Brambles, the Australian pallet-pooling group behind CHEP, described its business model as "globally consistent" and expected to report full ESRS at group level instead (New Zealand outreach event).
Amazon made the same point for integrated groups (US outreach event): they have no EU-dedicated product lines, supply chains or data systems, and collect workforce, emissions, water and waste data globally or regionally, not by market.
Alibaba said the location-based part "worked well" for its data centres, but the customer-based part is unclear for a marketplace because independent sellers may resell goods into the EU without Alibaba knowing (China outreach event).
Japan's accountancy institute, JICPA, raised similar problems (Japan outreach event): goods sold to a UK distributor but consumed in the EU, sales through agents, and intermediate goods built into other products.
Sungrow, also an exporter, can separate the products it sells to Europe, but its production lines, staff and supply chain are shared, so it asked which allocation keys EFRAG would accept. Chiara Del Prete said that was a request for "more flexibility than what is currently in the standard", and doubted whether revenue or volume keys fit the current wording (China outreach event).
Why some groups prefer global reporting or full ESRS
Dormakaba, the Swiss maker of locks, doors and access systems, which already reports on a double-materiality basis, argued against the mixed approach on principle: reporting only EU impacts adds complexity, and due diligence laws elsewhere already require groups to identify impacts globally (Swiss outreach event).
The Swiss Finance Council said its members lean towards full ESRS, which lets EU subsidiaries use the CSRD subsidiary exemption; an ESRS-40a report doesn't. In the Brazil outreach event, EFRAG confirmed that full ESRS at parent level would spare Suzano a second report.
A quick test for the mixed approach: are your targets set at group level?
If all your targets are set at group level, then the mixed approach may not suit you.
In the China outreach event, Chiara Del Prete confirmed that groups can reuse group policies and targets, but for topics limited to EU-related impacts, metrics must cover those impacts only.
That would leave an EU-related metric next to a group-wide target, a strange and unhelpful pairing. As the group target was set and resourced at group level, the progress of the EU-related metric would say little about whether the group was on track. Investors would judge the group against the group target, and an EU-related result next to it would be easy to misread. Hardly a decision-useful outcome.
Groups that manage their EU business separately often have EU-level targets already, and they are also the most likely to pass the paragraph 29 test.
What is still open: allocation keys, regional boundaries and own workforce
In the Canada outreach event, EFRAG described two directions the mixed approach might take after the consultation:
- Tighten the conditions so only groups with a genuinely separate EU business qualify, or
- Make the approach fully flexible so that groups can split shared impacts using conventional allocation keys, such as the share of revenue or production linked to the EU.
In the Japan outreach event, Gemma Sánchez Danés said there is "certain flexibility" on the method or allocation key, and that EFRAG's caution "could be misinterpreted".
In the UK outreach event, EFRAG said it had also heard calls for a wider regional boundary, such as an EMEA segment. In the Japan outreach event, Gemma Sánchez Danés said such a management unit "could" be used, and that two companies in the same sector could end up with different allocations.
Own workforce is a second open point. In the US outreach event, Gemma Sánchez Danés said own workforce "probably makes sense" reported globally, as climate is (and as in Daikin's example), because impacts on people don't divide neatly: counting 30% of an injury "doesn't make sense". That would narrow what the mixed approach removes.
How to decide whether the ESRS-40a mixed approach suits your group
To test whether your group can qualify for the mixed approach, and whether it's worth it, work through these four steps:
- Work out which type of group you are: a separate EU business, an exporter or a globally integrated group. Map where your EU-bound products, sites, staff and data sit, and whether any of them are managed separately. This map is your evidence for the next step.
- Check whether you can pass the paragraph 29 test. Document how your business is structured and managed, and test it under both strict conditions and flexible allocation.
- Estimate, topic by topic, what the boundary removes. Start from the EU nexus, as EFRAG explained in the Mexico outreach event: identify activities in the EU and products sold into the EU, then trace their impacts through the whole value chain.
- Compare the alternatives. Weigh the mixed approach against global reporting and full ESRS, including the subsidiary exemption.
ESRS-40a timeline and next steps
The consultation on ESRS-40a closes on 31 October 2026, and EFRAG plans to deliver its technical advice in early February 2027. The Commission aims to adopt the standard by mid-2027.
The mixed approach is not settled: EFRAG may tighten or loosen it after the consultation and field test.
Non-EU groups that start preparing now will be better placed to decide whether to use it, whichever way the final standard goes.
ReportingLab can help you choose the right reporting option for your group and prepare for ESRS-40a. Get in touch to find out more.
Frequently asked questions about the ESRS-40a mixed approach
How are EU-related impacts defined under the ESRS-40a mixed approach?
Under ESRS-40a 1 (paragraph 28), EU-related impacts have two parts, and both apply: the impacts of the group's activities in the EU, including their value chains (location-based), and impacts anywhere that are linked to products and services sold, or reasonably assumed to be sold, into the EU (customer-based).
What is the paragraph 29 test?
To use the mixed approach, a group must be able to make a "meaningful identification" of its EU-related impacts, in line with how its business and value chain are structured or managed. The draft's examples include a separate EU segment, EU-specific products and dedicated EU value chains (AR 6).
Which topics are always reported globally under the mixed approach?
Climate change (E1) is always reported globally. For other topics, a group can limit reporting to EU-related impacts topic by topic, or by sub-topic or group of impacts. In the US outreach event, Gemma Sánchez Danés said own workforce (S1) "probably makes sense" reported globally too.
When will ESRS-40a be finalised?
The consultation on the exposure draft closes on 31 October 2026. EFRAG plans to deliver its technical advice in early February 2027, and the European Commission aims to adopt the standard by mid-2027. Groups in scope will report from financial years starting in 2028.
This analysis is based on EFRAG’s July 2026 exposure draft and nine public outreach events held by EFRAG in September and October 2026.
Share this article


